Top Ten Myths about Emerging Church

26
01

2010
16:37

Short list (for posterity’s sake) of Tony Jones‘ list of Top Ten Myths about the Emerging Church, delivered at Emergence Now at Columbia Theological Seminary January 27, 2010, and reported real time via Bruce Reyes-Chow (who is there as well) through Twitter with @breyeschow.

#1 ”Emergence is just about theological debates and publishing contracts.”

#2 ”Emergence only appeals to younger people.”

#3 ”Emergence is a reformation of evangelicalism.”

#4 ”Emergence does not believe in authority.”

#5 ”Emergence is confined to the American church and white guys.”

#6 ”Emergence doesn’t appreciate church history.”

#7 ”Emergence has a spokesperson.”

#8 ”Emergence is a new way to ‘do church’.”

#8.5 “Pomomusings is the official blog of the emergent church.”

#9 ”Emergence is anti-denominational”

#10 ”Emergence is trying to put the conventional church out of business.”

UPDATE 1/27 : Tony posted the slides from yesterday’s talk here.

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

Emergent/Emerging | Tags: , , ,

Comments

Comment from Parker @ 2010.01.26 - 18:11

If there is no…or are no…spokespersons for emergence, why do the same names keep emerging in the conversations or conferences about it?”

Comment from Rachel @ 2010.01.26 - 18:18

I agree with Parker. Sounds a bit like denial. What path of emergence are you referring to btw? What about the myth that emergent means de-Jesusing the message within the church?

Comment from Callid @ 2010.01.26 - 18:59

@Parker: I tend to agree as well. What’s more, I don’t get why everyone (or some) seems to get so squeamish when it is suggested there are spokespeople. A spokesperson is not the same thing as a leader I don’t think. Why is this such a touchy subject?

@Rachel: I wasn’t there myself so I don’t know what exactly he said, but I would imagine that he was probably talking about emergent village (and similar) connected “paths,” as that where I associate him, but, I don’t know. Interestingly re: “de-Jesusing,” among my folk, The Religious Society of Friends (Quakers), the Emergent-inspired conversation is about re-Jesusing our tradition. So I for one would agree that that is a myth.

Comment from Andrew @ 2010.01.26 - 20:08

I would have really loved someone to defend the vagueness that seems to typify most emergents. There are hip writers and speakers who don’t have to resort to ambiguousness to get their message across, and yet I find it hard to nail down what emergent writers stand for.

Comment from Callid @ 2010.01.26 - 21:04

@Andrew: Here’s the crux of it for me, which might be different than your beef: There are ways of being clear without putting forth totalizing doctrinal statements that you insist on being absolutely true for everyone. I feel like some folk believe that if they say what they believe to be true it will be tantamount to launching an attack. It isn’t.

Comment from justin @ 2010.01.26 - 22:52

duh! anyone can tell you what the emergent movement isn’t

Comment from Parker @ 2010.01.26 - 22:57

Callid…I agree…I wonder if there is anything intrinsically wrong with a leader as opposed to the ways in which one leads that’s problematic

Comment from Dave H. @ 2010.01.27 - 00:21

Callid – thanks for posting this! Pretty cool that tech on the ground can get this up for us so fast.

“If there is no…or are no…spokespersons for emergence, why do the same names keep emerging in the conversations or conferences about it?”

Emergence Christianity privileges local knowledge and truth, not the blogging or publishing of strangers. My local congregation is very emergent. But we have no need of a national spokesperson or leader. A popular way of critiquing emerging church is to argue against supposed leaders as if they represent what is going on from congregation to congregation. They don’t. My spokespersons are the people sitting next to me: John Buckwalter, Connie Finney, Ernie Lipscomb, and Beth Stevick. The critique that matters to me is a critique of them.

I’ve tried to describe my thinking and experience as best as I can here, I hope this can be helpful to someone trying to understand what I’m about.

Comment from parker @ 2010.01.27 - 01:57

my response to #8 was not a critique of the entire movement (a movement about which i understand quite a bit), so the question remains: if #8 truly is a myth, then why are John Buckwalter, Connie Finney, Ernie Lipscomb, and Beth Stevick or a collective gathering of other “emergence participants” (for lack of a better phrase) not invited to speak about their views and experiences of (not on behalf of) emergence? it’s difficult to dodge outside critique because you claim to lack structure or by simply asserting that outsiders to that structureless system just don’t “get it.” there is an appearance to the movement that even sympathetic observers might have questions about

Comment from Adam Walker Cleaveland @ 2010.01.27 - 02:12

Just wanted to clarify…….#8.5 was actually:

#8.5 “Pomomusings is not the official blog of the emergent church.”

;)

Comment from parker @ 2010.01.27 - 02:46

oops…actually i meant #7 as you could probably tell

Comment from Dave H. @ 2010.01.27 - 03:45

Hey Parker,

I get that you weren’t critiquing an entire movement, I’m sorry that wasn’t clear.

John Buckwalter, Connie Finney, Ernie Lipscomb, and Beth Stevick are invited to speak about their views and experiences all the time. Every week, even daily, I and my friends are in deep conversation and dialogue with them. This is what I’m saying, the radically local conversation is what matters and where authority, leadership, even representation is found. A stranger with a book deal does not speak for us. He or she is an interesting conversation partner.

Pingback from Tweets that mention The Image of Fish » Top Ten Myths about Emerging Church — Topsy.com @ 2010.01.27 - 06:40

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Emergent Village, Jay Bakker, Tony Jones, Amy Moffitt, Queermergent and others. Queermergent said: RT @EmergentJesus: if these are myths, then so was my resurrection (@tonyjones) http://ow.ly/10Jll [...]

Comment from Matthew Gallion @ 2010.01.28 - 06:32

As a person who is attempting to do academic research on emergence, I have to identify so-called “spokespersons.” I also have to deal a lot with taxonomies and generalizations. All of these things are somewhat unfaithful to the ideals of emerging thought. For me, the issue at hand is how to understand what the emerging church movement is. Is it actually a movement? From a sociological perspective, it certainly is. It has a specific language, certain uniformity, and even these spokespersons.

But theologically, emergence is much more like what @Dave H. describes. It exists locally. It affects communities and relationships. Emergence, in this regard, is not a movement, but an ethos. The terms “emerging” and “emergent” only serve to temporarily describe the Church’s need to constantly re-evaluate. And as far as these spokespersons go in this regard, they provide individuals in separate contexts a starting point for conversation.

I once heard Tony Jones say that writing and promoting his books was the single most profane thing that he does. In other words, it’s just a job. And I think he does it well. But just how much authority we give a person who is just doing his or her job is something that each of us must decide.

Comment from Matthew Gallion @ 2010.01.28 - 14:09

Speaking along these lines, Shane Claiborne and Jonathan Wilson-Hartgrove discussed something very similar on Sojourners recently.

http://is.gd/7eF3b

The way Claiborne talks of intentionally trying to not be someone’s spokesperson makes me wonder. Does one choose to be a spokesperson, or are spokespersons deemed such by those who embrace their words? In other words, can Claiborne actually succeed in his endeavor to not be a spokesperson?

Also, I totally agree with what he said. I’ll probably start quoting him on it all the time.

Comment from Katie Jo @ 2010.02.02 - 11:21

Just a different perspective to add to the “spokesperson” conversation. I didn’t know I counted as “emergent” or even what emergent really was until about six months ago when a friend told me that the way I thought of church was “emergent.” I had only read one book by a so-called spokesperson, but I came to think in what I now call “missional” and “emergent” ways because of the influence of studying Methodist history and reading accounts of American Pentecostal revivals. I just thought of it as “the way my generation would want religion.” I think there are lots of folks out there doing things we would call “emergent,” but not calling it that because they came to it through a completely different path. Perhaps we are giving too much credit to the “spokespersons”…

Comment from NadiaFulton34 @ 2010.04.06 - 08:57

The college essay and essays writing takes a long period of time, but time can be a valuable issue, thence it will be worth to buy custom term paper to save time.

Comment from custom write @ 2010.07.03 - 09:54

Normal
0

false
false
false

MicrosoftInternetExplorer4

/* Style Definitions */
table.MsoNormalTable
{mso-style-name:”Обычная таблица”;
mso-tstyle-rowband-size:0;
mso-tstyle-colband-size:0;
mso-style-noshow:yes;
mso-style-parent:”";
mso-padding-alt:0cm 5.4pt 0cm 5.4pt;
mso-para-margin:0cm;
mso-para-margin-bottom:.0001pt;
mso-pagination:widow-orphan;
font-size:10.0pt;
font-family:”Times New Roman”;
mso-ansi-language:#0400;
mso-fareast-language:#0400;
mso-bidi-language:#0400;}

Commonly, teachers want to check out the term paper essays creative writing ability of some their students, but not all good students can to write professionally because of no time and other things. Hence, a <a href="http://www.solidpapers.com">paper writing service</a> would help to accomplish the <a href="http://www.solidpapers.com">term paper</a> very fast.

Comment from university essay @ 2010.07.05 - 08:00

Normal
0

false
false
false

MicrosoftInternetExplorer4

/* Style Definitions */
table.MsoNormalTable
{mso-style-name:”Обычная таблица”;
mso-tstyle-rowband-size:0;
mso-tstyle-colband-size:0;
mso-style-noshow:yes;
mso-style-parent:”";
mso-padding-alt:0cm 5.4pt 0cm 5.4pt;
mso-para-margin:0cm;
mso-para-margin-bottom:.0001pt;
mso-pagination:widow-orphan;
font-size:10.0pt;
font-family:”Times New Roman”;
mso-ansi-language:#0400;
mso-fareast-language:#0400;
mso-bidi-language:#0400;}

 
It's well known that the essay papers accomplishing procedure can be annoying. Therefore, smart persons do not waste their free time and buy essays . Moreover, that is not a kind of cheating, I opine!

Comment from NFL Jerseys @ 2010.07.19 - 20:26

hey,you have posted such a effectful article that it will certainly help me.

Comment from cosplay @ 2010.08.09 - 04:36

hey,you have posted such a effectful article that it will certainly help me.

Comment from seo agency @ 2010.08.11 - 06:02

I just couldn't leave your website before telling you that we really enjoyed the quality information you offer to your visitors…

Comment from Personal Statements @ 2010.08.20 - 02:03

i really like your blog and the way it designed and functionality. How did you do it?

Nice information given to us in here..

Anyways, If you’re frustrated and don’t know the way to accomplish the papers for money, you would have an opportunity to buy a research paper in the progressive admission essay writing service. It should really save your free time and money.

Comment from wilderness program @ 2010.08.20 - 22:10

This is truly an amazing blog and this is quiet good to read. A very nice article.
 
Hope there is still new also to be shared.

Comment from small business loan program @ 2010.08.21 - 01:33

Nice blog. But just how much authority we give a person who is just doing his or her job is something that each of us must decide.

Comment from cheap jerseys @ 2010.08.30 - 19:40

Perhaps this is one of the most interesting blogs that I have ever seen. Interesting article, Funny comment. Keep it up! 

Comment from home loans @ 2010.09.02 - 08:23

If you are willing to buy a car, you would have to receive the loan. Moreover, my father commonly uses a college loan, which occurs to be really rapid.

Comment from raiders jersey @ 2010.09.03 - 02:26

Really interesting articles. I enjoyed reading it

Comment from color surveillance camera @ 2010.09.06 - 04:23

This is a great article thanks for sharing this informative information.. I will visit your blog regularly for some latest post.

 

Comment from Turning Winds @ 2010.09.07 - 02:56

Would love to know more about this myth and discover some of it to know.

Write a comment!





Comment feed for this post

«

»

Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes